Buffalo Milk on Catalina Island: The Legendary Cocktail You Must Try
When visiting Catalina Island, most people think of sun-soaked beaches, crystal-clear waters, and laid-back island vibes. But there’s one delicious surprise that keeps both locals and visitors buzzing: the iconic Buffalo Milk cocktail.
Whether you’re a cocktail enthusiast or just love trying local specialties, Buffalo Milk is a must-have experience—and here at Catalina Courtyard Suites, we’re excited to share the inside scoop on where to find it and how to enjoy it island-style.
🍹 What Is Buffalo Milk?
Don’t worry—there’s no actual buffalo milk in this famous Catalina Island drink. The name pays homage to the American bison that roam the island’s interior, but the cocktail itself is a creamy, dreamy blend of:
-
Vodka
-
Kahlúa
-
Crème de banana
-
Crème de cacao
-
Fresh cream
-
Topped with whipped cream and a sprinkle of nutmeg
It’s a tropical milkshake with a grown-up twist—smooth, sweet, and absolutely unforgettable.
🥂 Where to Try Buffalo Milk in Avalon
You can’t leave Catalina without sipping on this signature island cocktail. Here are the top local spots serving the best Buffalo Milk on Catalina Island:
Luau Larry’s
Widely recognized as the birthplace of Buffalo Milk, this Avalon favorite offers a fun tiki-bar vibe, tropical cocktails, and live music. It’s a must-stop on your island itinerary.
Descanso Beach Club
Sip Buffalo Milk with your toes in the sand and unbeatable views of the ocean. This upscale beachside hangout delivers drinks, cabanas, and luxury lounging just steps from the surf.
El Galleon
A lively hotspot with karaoke, hearty seafood, and a legendary bar. Grab a Buffalo Milk, sing your heart out, and enjoy the fun side of Avalon nightlife.
The Sand Trap
A local hidden gem, The Sand Trap serves up delicious Buffalo Milk with a relaxed, no-frills vibe. Great for brunch or a casual afternoon drink.
💬 Why Is Buffalo Milk So Popular?
Buffalo Milk has become Catalina Island’s signature cocktail because it captures everything the island represents: fun, relaxation, and a splash of the unexpected. Whether you’re enjoying it beachside at Descanso or belting out karaoke at El Galleon, this drink is more than just a beverage—it’s a Catalina tradition.
🏨 Stay Near the Best Buffalo Milk Spots
When you stay at Catalina Courtyard Suites, you’re just steps from Avalon’s best bars, beach clubs, and restaurants serving this iconic cocktail. Our centrally located Catalina Island hotel offers:
-
Spacious, island-inspired suites with balconies or patios
-
Easy walking distance to Descanso Beach Club, Luau Larry’s, and downtown Avalon
-
Personalized recommendations from locals who love sharing the island’s best-kept secrets
Whether you’re celebrating a romantic anniversary, a birthday, or simply need a relaxing getaway, we’ll help you craft your perfect stay—including plenty of Buffalo Milk along the way.
🌟 Pro Tip
Ask for a twist on the classic: some bartenders add a splash of chocolate syrup, use coconut milk for a tropical feel, or sprinkle cinnamon for an extra kick. And don’t forget to snap a photo—this cocktail is as Instagram-worthy as it is delicious!
📅 Book Your Catalina Island Getaway Today
Ready to sip a Buffalo Milk by the beach with the ocean breeze in your hair? Catalina Courtyard Suites is your home base for all things Avalon. Book direct on our website to unlock exclusive savings and start planning your island adventure today.
Catalina Courtyard Suites
Your Island Escape Starts Here.
www.catalinacourtyardsuites.com
📍 Avalon, Catalina Island, CA
