Catalina Courtyard Suites

Red-brick driveway lined with skinny trees, plants and bushes

Best Buffalo Milk on Catalina Island

Although it is not common knowledge, Catalina Island is, in fact, home to a large herd of wild bison. With the heavy presence of these animals, Buffalo Milk has been termed the official drink of Catalina Island.

So, where can you find the best Buffalo Milk on Catalina Island? Let’s find out…

What Is Buffalo Milk?

First of all, let’s talk about what Buffalo Milk is. Contrary to what you might think, Buffalo Milk does not come from the buffalo on the island. The Buffalo Milk that Catalina Island is known for is an adult beverage, best-enjoyed beachside.

Buffalo Milk is similar to a White Russian but with an added Catalina Island twist. Here’s the recipe:

  • 1/2 shot of Creme de Cocoa
  • 1/2 shot of Kahlua
  • 1/2 shot of Creme de Banana
  • One shot of vodka
  • Half & half

Blend all of these ingredients together with some ice and top it all off with whipped cream. Garnish your beverage with some nutmeg and a banana slice, and you’ve got yourself a proper Buffalo Milk.

History of Buffalo Milk

Bartender Michael Hoffler is to thank for the creation of this creamy treat of a drink. At the time, Hoffler was working at Doug’s, now known as Two Harbors, in Harbor Reef. Hoffler was known for making up drinks and testing them out, but the Buffalo Milk was an instant hit.

Best Buffalo Milk on Catalina Island

Today Buffalo Milk is such a hit that you can easily find it all over the island. Here are just a few of our favorites that have the signature Buffalo Milk on their menus:

  • Antoni’s Pizzeria
  • Bluewater Avalon
  • Coyote Joe’s
  • Descanso Beach Club
  • El Galleon
  • Harbor Reef (where Buffalo Milk originated)
  • Harbor Sands
  • Luau Larry’s
  • Maggie’s Blue Rose
  • Steve’s Steakhouse & Seafood
  • The Cover Bar & Grill
  • Toyon Grill

Catalina Hot Spots

Catalina Hot Spots is the place to find all of the hot spots, including where to find the best Buffalo Milk on Catalina Island. Are you looking for specials or events? Or are you interested in setting up a banquet? Let us help you! 

Toll Free: 855-891-3400Booking directly with us and you will get the best rate guaranteed Book Now
trip advisor logo
California Association of Boutique and Breakfast Inns logo